Sam and Dean run a hole-in-the wall bar that specializes in tap beer and lots of whiskey. Benny’s there enough to have his own barstool, that the other regulars are aware not to take. He lingers longer and longer every night, spending more time talking to the brothers than actually drinking any of the beers put in front of him. Finally, Dean blushes and stutters his way through an invitation to come home with them – them, and that’s how Benny finds out they share a lot more than just a last name.
… and there’s like another 25k of this somewhere, right?!